2026 Simply Copycat Recipes Breadstick Roundup

Every breadstick, cheesy bread, and bread bite copycat on this blog in one place, sorted by style, with the dough details, dipping sauces, and gluten-free and dairy-free swaps that actually work.

Here is something I have noticed after a year of testing pizza-shop sides in my own kitchen: nobody remembers the pizza. They remember the bread. The basket that hits the table first at Olive Garden. The little box of Crazy Bread you eat in the car. The stuffed cheesy bread that pulls apart in long strings and burns the roof of your mouth because you would not wait five minutes.

From soft garlic breadsticks and cheesy pan breads to stuffed bread, Parmesan bites, and garlic knots, this 2026 roundup brings 15 copycat bread recipes together with dough tips, garlic butter toppings, dipping sauces, and easy swaps.

This is the 2026 Simply Copycat Recipes Breadstick Roundup, and it pulls all of those recipes together into one guide. Instead of listing them by the date I published them, I organized them the way you actually choose: what shape and style you are in the mood for. Plain buttery breadsticks. Cheese-covered or cheese-stuffed. Or pull-apart bites and knots. Then I broke out the parts that carry the flavor, which is really the garlic butter and the dipping sauce.

If you have never made yeast dough before, start anywhere in the first section. Every one of these is the same basic idea: wake up the yeast, mix a soft dough, let it rise, shape it, bake it hot, and brush it with garlic butter the second it comes out of the oven. That last step is not optional. It is the whole trick.

Style 1: Classic Breadsticks

These are the no-cheese-on-top breadsticks. Soft dough, golden outside, and a garlic butter finish doing most of the heavy lifting. If you want a basket of bread to set next to a pot of spaghetti, this is your section.

Olive Garden Breadsticks

The one everyone asks about. My copycat Olive Garden breadsticks recipe makes about a dozen, and the dough is on the sweeter side for a savory bread, with two tablespoons of sugar and three tablespoons of melted butter mixed right in. That is what gives them the pillowy, almost dinner-roll interior instead of a crusty bakery texture. Knead it a full 8 to 10 minutes by hand until a small piece stretches thin without tearing, rise about an hour, then bake 12 to 15 minutes and hit them with garlic salt butter while they are hot.

Yield: 12 breadsticks, about 140 calories each
Best for: pasta night, soup, salad, or eating standing at the counter
Key detail: onion powder in the topping, which is the small thing most copycats leave out

Fazoli’s Breadsticks

Fazoli’s breadsticks are richer and a touch chewier than Olive Garden’s, and the reason is the flour. My copycat Fazoli’s breadsticks recipe uses bread flour instead of all-purpose, which builds a little more structure so you get that soft-but-springy pull. The topping is heavier too: four tablespoons of melted butter with garlic powder and salt, brushed on generously so they come out glossy. Twelve breadsticks, 12 to 14 minutes in the oven, about 170 calories apiece.

If you ask me, this is the best one to make when the breadsticks are the meal. They are substantial enough to stand on their own with a bowl of marinara.

Little Caesars Crazy Bread

Crazy Bread is the lightest of the bunch, and the flavor is almost entirely in the finish. The Little Caesars Crazy Bread copycat leans on garlic butter and a heavy shower of Parmesan and herbs right out of the oven, not on cheese baked into the top. That is what makes it different from the Italian Cheese Bread from the same chain, and why it stays a breadstick rather than turning into cheesy bread.

Tear one apart while it is still steaming and you get that gentle stretch and a wave of garlic. Marinara on the side is optional here, but I never actually skip it.

Papa John’s Breadsticks

These are the fluffiest in the roundup. My copycat Papa John’s breadsticks recipe runs a longer rise, 60 to 75 minutes, and yields 12 to 16 sticks depending on how you slice them. The inside stays soft and airy, the outside picks up just enough crispness, and they are built specifically for dunking in warm pizza sauce. No mixer required, just a bowl, a pan, and some patience while the dough does its thing.

Papa John’s fans know the special garlic sauce is half the reason to order. Melted butter with extra garlic on the side covers it nicely.

Hungry Howie’s Howie Bread

Howie Bread is the fastest route to warm breadsticks in this whole guide, because it starts from a pressed rectangle rather than individually shaped sticks. In the copycat Hungry Howie’s Howie Bread recipe you press the dough into a rough 9x13 shape on the pan, brush it with olive oil, then pre-score it with a pizza cutter without cutting all the way through. It bakes 12 to 16 minutes, then pulls apart cleanly along the scored lines.

That scoring trick is worth stealing for any of these. It gives you clean breadstick shapes without the fuss of rolling ropes, and the pieces stay connected while they bake so they steam each other and stay tender.

Style 2: Cheesy Bread

Now we add cheese, either melted across the top or sealed inside. Every recipe in this section bakes hot, usually 425°F, because you want the cheese bubbling and browning in spots before the crust dries out.

Cheese On Top

The copycat Little Caesars Italian Cheese Bread is the benchmark: a full sheet pan of dough pressed to the edges, then a blend of mozzarella, mild cheddar, and Parmesan taken all the way out to the corners. Those browned, crispy cheese edges are the best part and you only get them if the cheese touches the pan. Bake at 425°F for 14 to 18 minutes, brush with garlic butter twice (once before, once after), and cut into 12 pieces.

The Pizza Hut cheesy breadsticks copycat follows the same idea but bakes a few minutes longer at 15 to 18 minutes, and gets cut into strips and then crosswise for those shorter, wider sticks you remember from the red plastic tray. The Mr. Gatti’s cheese sticks recipe adds provolone alongside the mozzarella, which is a small change that makes a real difference; provolone browns a little more aggressively and adds a sharper edge that plain mozzarella does not have.

My copycat Papa John’s cheesesticks use the same mozzarella and provolone combination on a 425°F bake, cut into 8 long strips with a pizza cutter after a 3 to 5 minute rest. That rest matters. Cut too soon and the cheese slides off the strip you are trying to lift.

The Cheeser Howie Bread copycat is the pan-style version of Howie Bread, same pressed-dough base but loaded with cheese and baked 14 to 18 minutes into 8 pieces. If you like the buttery Howie seasoning but want it cheesy, this is the one.

Do not overload the cheese. Every one of these recipes warns about it for the same reason: too much cheese insulates the top and the center of the dough bakes unevenly.
Check the center. Baked pizza-style dough is done around 190°F to 200°F internally.
Rest 3 to 5 minutes before cutting so the cheese sets enough to hold together.

Cheese Inside

Two recipes here seal the cheese in instead of scattering it on top. Domino’s Stuffed Cheesy Bread is basically a cross between cheesy garlic bread and a calzone: soft dough wrapped around a stretchy cheese filling, sealed, then finished with a garlicky butter topping and baked until golden. It is the messiest one to assemble and easily the most satisfying to pull apart.

Jet’s Pizza Turbo Stix take a different route. You roll the dough into a 10x14 rectangle, fill and fold, then cut into 8 strips before baking, so each stick has cheese running through the middle. If the dough gets slack while you work, chill it about 10 minutes before slicing and the strips hold their shape much better.

Style 3: Bread Bites and Garlic Knots

Same dough, different shape, completely different eating experience. Bites and knots are finger food. You set them out on a platter with two or three dips and they disappear before the main course arrives.

Domino’s Parmesan Bread Bites

My copycat Domino’s Parmesan Bread Bites recipe cuts the dough into small pieces and bakes them nestled close together, 12 to 15 minutes, until the tops are lightly golden. Think of it like baking dinner rolls: when the pieces cozy up next to each other on the pan, they stay tender instead of drying into little croutons. Half the garlic butter goes on before baking, half after. Six servings of about four bites each.

Papa John’s Garlic Knots

The Papa John’s garlic knots copycat is the most traditional bread project in this roundup and the only one with a true second rise. You divide the dough into 16 pieces, roll each into a rope, tie it, then let the shaped knots rise another 15 to 20 minutes before baking at 400°F for 12 to 15 minutes. That second rise is what gives you the puffed, rounded top instead of a flat tied lump.

Brush lightly with garlic butter before baking, then generously right after, and add the Parmesan and parsley while they are still hot so it sticks.

Bubba’s 33 Garlic Knots

The Bubba’s 33 garlic knots recipe puts the Parmesan into the butter mixture itself rather than only sprinkling it on afterward. You melt the butter with minced garlic, olive oil, parsley, Italian seasoning, salt, and grated Parmesan, then coat the knots in it. The result is a glossier, more restaurant-style finish where the cheese is part of the sauce clinging to the bread.

One warning that applies to every knot recipe: cook the garlic gently for about a minute, just until fragrant. Burnt garlic turns bitter fast and there is no fixing it once it happens.

Dough Basics and the Shortcuts That Actually Work

Fourteen of these fifteen recipes start from a nearly identical dough. Once you see the pattern, you stop needing a recipe at all.

Water temperature: 105°F to 110°F, every single time. Warm on your finger, never hot. Above 120°F kills the yeast, and that is the number one reason homemade breadsticks come out dense.
Proof first: sugar and yeast in the warm water for 5 to 10 minutes. If it does not foam, throw it out and start over. It is much cheaper to lose a packet of yeast than an hour of rise time.
Flour choice: all-purpose for soft and pillowy, bread flour when you want a chewier pull like the Fazoli’s version.
Dough feel: soft and slightly tacky, never stiff. Nearly every troubleshooting note in these posts traces back to the same mistake, which is too much flour. Add it a tablespoon at a time or not at all.
Rise: 45 to 60 minutes for most, up to 75 for the fluffiest. A turned-off oven with the light on is the easiest warm spot in a cold kitchen.
Doneness: 190°F to 200°F in the center of the bread. Golden on top does not always mean cooked in the middle.

Store-bought pizza dough works in every recipe here. Let it sit out 20 to 30 minutes so it stretches instead of snapping back, then skip straight to the shaping step. I do this on weeknights without guilt.

Air fryer versions show up across the board, and the settings are consistent: 375°F for roughly 7 to 10 minutes for pan-style cheesy breads and knots, 350°F for 6 to 9 minutes for smaller bites. Check early the first time, since air fryers brown tops much faster than an oven does.

Reheating is where most leftover breadsticks go to die. Skip the microwave unless you want soft and slightly rubbery. Oven at 325°F to 350°F for 5 to 10 minutes, or the air fryer at 325°F for 2 to 5 minutes, brings back the crust. Reheat to 165°F to be safe.

Garlic Butter and Toppings

The topping is the personality of a breadstick. Same dough, four different butters, four completely different breads.

Garlic salt style: melted butter, garlic powder, onion powder, fine salt. Simple and salty, the Olive Garden signature.
Buttery garlic powder style: a heavier pour of butter with garlic powder and salt, sometimes Parmesan and parsley for color. This is the Fazoli’s finish and the richest of the group.
Fresh minced garlic style: butter melted with olive oil and fresh minced garlic, cooked gently about a minute. Sharper and more aromatic, used in the garlic knot recipes.
Italian herb style: butter, minced garlic, garlic powder, Italian seasoning, and oregano, used on the Italian Cheese Bread and the pan cheesy breads.

Two habits that improved every batch I made: brush half before and half after baking so the flavor is both baked in and fresh on top, and add Parmesan and parsley while the bread is still hot so it actually sticks instead of rolling off onto the pan.

Dipping Sauces

Warm marinara is the default across every recipe on this blog, and for good reason. It is tangy, and that acidity cuts through all the butter. But it is not the only option, and a few of these breads are noticeably better with something else.

Marinara or pizza sauce: the universal answer. Warm it up first, even from a jar. Cold sauce on hot bread is a waste of a good breadstick. If you are reheating sauce that has been sitting, bring it to 165°F.
Ranch: the go-to for the cheesy ones. It is the classic pairing with Domino’s Stuffed Cheesy Bread and Papa John’s cheesesticks, where the richness of the bread wants something cool and tangy rather than more tomato.
Garlic butter dip: the Papa John’s move. Extra melted butter with garlic in a small cup on the side. It sounds like too much and it is exactly right with the plain breadsticks.
Cheese sauce: called out as a game-day option with Crazy Bread, where the bread is plain enough to carry a heavier dip.
Alfredo: listed with the Parmesan Bread Bites, and it is the one I would pick for a bite-sized bread that can hold a thicker sauce without falling apart.
Olive oil: the simplest option, and the one I recommend in the Fazoli’s breadsticks post if you want something lighter than butter on butter.

Hosting? Cut whatever you baked into smaller pieces and set out three dips instead of one. It is the single easiest way to make a pan of breadsticks feel like an actual appetizer spread. People always gather around the bread first anyway.

Gluten-Free and Dairy-Free Options

Yes, and this is one of the areas where the recipes on this blog go further than a simple “use a gluten-free flour” note. A few of the workarounds are specific enough to be worth collecting here.

Gluten-Free

Use a 1:1 blend made for yeast baking, and check for xanthan gum. The Fazoli’s and Papa John’s garlic knots posts both call this out specifically. If your blend does not include xanthan gum, add it. Without it there is nothing holding the structure together and you get crumble instead of bread.
Press, do not roll. This is the most useful gluten-free tip in the whole collection, and it shows up in the Mr. Gatti’s, Howie Bread, Papa John’s cheesesticks, and Italian Cheese Bread recipes. Gluten-free dough is softer and stickier, so press it into the pan with lightly oiled hands instead of fighting it with a rolling pin.
Shape rolls instead of knots. The garlic knots post has the smartest fix for shaping: if gluten-free dough is too fragile to tie, do not try. Roll it into small rounds and treat them as garlic rolls. Same butter, same flavor, no tearing.
Chill before slicing. For the stuffed Turbo Stix, refrigerating the filled dough about 10 minutes firms it up enough to cut clean strips, which is otherwise nearly impossible with a soft gluten-free dough.
Check the bake time early. The Cheeser Howie Bread post notes that some gluten-free doughs bake faster, so start checking several minutes before the recipe time.
The sauce is the hidden risk. Multiple posts flag it and it is worth repeating: marinara, pizza sauce, ranch, seasoning blends, and even some grated Parmesan can carry gluten. The bread is the easy part. Read the jar.

Dairy-Free

Most of these doughs are already dairy-free. Every one of them is egg-free, and the plain breadstick doughs at Papa John’s and Olive Garden are dairy-free the moment you swap the butter for vegan butter or a neutral oil. Nothing else changes.
Vegan butter beats oil for the topping. The Fazoli’s post makes the distinction clearly: olive oil works in the dough, but for that rich restaurant-style finish on top, plant-based butter is the better swap.
Nutritional yeast instead of Parmesan. Recommended in the Crazy Bread and Bubba’s 33 garlic knots recipes, and it does the savory, salty job better than most dairy-free Parmesan alternatives.
Not all dairy-free shreds melt the same. For the cheesy breads, the Mr. Gatti’s post is specific about looking for a mozzarella-style shred known for good stretch and browning, not just any bag labeled dairy-free.
Lactose-free is a separate option. The Papa John’s cheesesticks recipe suggests lactose-free mozzarella if you can find it, which keeps real dairy melt and stretch for anyone who is sensitive rather than allergic.
Skip creamy dips. The Howie Bread post makes the point that ranch and cheese sauce undo all of the effort. Marinara is naturally dairy-free.
Check store-bought dough. Called out in the Turbo Stix and Stuffed Cheesy Bread posts. Most basic pizza doughs are naturally vegan, but some contain milk, butter, or honey.

With those swaps, nearly every recipe in this roundup becomes fully vegan without changing the method at all. The texture shifts a little, but the garlic-bread comfort factor holds up.

Quick Reference Chart

Recipe	Style	Yield	Bake Time	What Sets It Apart
Olive Garden Breadsticks	Breadstick	12 sticks	12–15 min	Garlic salt butter
Fazoli’s Breadsticks	Breadstick	12 sticks	12–14 min	Bread flour, extra butter
Little Caesars Crazy Bread	Breadstick	1 batch	12–15 min	Parmesan and herb finish
Papa John’s Breadsticks	Breadstick	12–16 sticks	12–15 min	Long rise, fluffiest
Hungry Howie’s Howie Bread	Breadstick	8 servings	12–16 min	Pre-scored pan bread
Little Caesars Italian Cheese Bread	Cheesy bread	12 pieces	14–18 min	Mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan
Pizza Hut Cheesy Breadsticks	Cheesy bread	12 sticks	15–18 min	Cut into short wide sticks
Mr. Gatti’s Cheese Sticks	Cheesy bread	8 servings	12–15 min	Mozzarella and provolone
Papa John’s Cheesesticks	Cheesy bread	8 strips	12–16 min	Rest before cutting
Hungry Howie’s Cheeser Howie Bread	Cheesy bread	8 pieces	14–18 min	Cheesy pan version
Domino’s Stuffed Cheesy Bread	Stuffed	1 loaf	Until golden	Cheese sealed inside
Jet’s Pizza Turbo Stix	Stuffed	8 sticks	14–18 min	Filled, folded, then sliced
Domino’s Parmesan Bread Bites	Bites	24 bites	12–15 min	Baked close together
Papa John’s Garlic Knots	Knots	16 knots	12–15 min	Second rise after shaping
Bubba’s 33 Garlic Knots	Knots	1 batch	Until golden	Parmesan mixed into butter

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did my breadsticks come out dense?

Almost always one of two things: too much flour, or yeast that never activated. The dough should feel soft and slightly tacky, not stiff. And if your water and yeast did not foam up in 5 to 10 minutes, the dough was never going to rise.

Can I make the dough ahead of time?

Yes. Most of these doughs refrigerate overnight, or up to 24 hours, after kneading. Let the dough sit at room temperature for 20 to 30 minutes before shaping so it is workable.

What is the difference between cheese sticks and breadsticks?

Breadsticks are finished with garlic butter and maybe a sprinkle of Parmesan. Cheese sticks and cheesy breads have shredded cheese melted across the top or sealed inside, which means a hotter oven, a shorter window, and a required rest before you cut them.

Which recipe is best for a beginner?

Hungry Howie’s Howie Bread. You press the dough into a rectangle, brush with oil, score it, and bake. No rolling ropes, no tying knots, no cheese to overload.

Can I freeze these?

Yes. Bake first, cool completely, then freeze in a sealed container for up to 2 months. Reheat from frozen in a 375°F oven until hot all the way through.

What dipping sauce is best?

Warm marinara for anything plain or garlicky, ranch for anything heavy with cheese, and garlic butter when you want to go all in. Set out all three if you are feeding a crowd.

Final Thoughts

Fifteen recipes, and they all come back to the same handful of moves: warm water, a soft dough, a real rise, a hot oven, and garlic butter the second it comes out. Learn those and you can make any pizza-shop bread you want, whether you are chasing the basket at Olive Garden, the box from Little Caesars, or the pull-apart pan of Domino’s Stuffed Cheesy Bread.

If you make one of these, come back and tell me which dip you went with. I am firmly on team warm marinara, but I have been told I am wrong about that.

Disclaimer

These are copycat recipes inspired by popular restaurant menu items. They are not the actual restaurant recipes, and this blog is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any of the restaurants or brands mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners. Nutrition information is approximate and will vary by brand and portion size. Always check ingredient labels if you are cooking for someone with a food allergy.

Search This Blog